The Best Carry On Luggage For Every Trip Type

Some posts contain affiliate links. I make a small commission if you buy from my links, at no extra cost to you. Thanks for supporting my site.

Open the storage cupboard in my house and it’s stacked with luggage. As someone who’s a frequent flyer, I’ve gathered a lot of suitcases over the years and I now seem to have one for every kind of trip. From lightweight carry on to hard shell luggage, to soft travel packs that squeeze into airline overhead bins, in this article I’ll share the best carry on luggage for every trip. I don’t have a lot of recommendations because I don’t think you need them.

If you’re not sure about switching to carry on, I’ve listed the pros and cons below. I’ve also got a handy link for the cabin luggage requirements for all major airlines. You might also like my article: How to Travel Light: 25 Quick Swaps for Packing Light.

Best for European Budget Airlines – Samsonite Ascentra

Sale
Samsonite Ascentra Softside Luggage, Checked-Large...
106 Reviews
Samsonite Ascentra Softside Luggage, Checked-Large…
  • RightHeight handle system with multi-stop…
  • Dual spinner wheels create a balanced and smooth…
  • Recyclex Material Technology-The exterior and…

This is currently my go-to small carry on luggage. At first, I couldn’t make up my mind up about this suitcase. It’s super lightweight, incredibly roomy, has great pockets, a TSA-compliant lock, and looks smart. However, the handle isn’t a smooth glide and the lining of the external pocket has a very small opening relative to the size of the space. For the price, I was initially disappointed.

Still, I can’t get over how light it is and how much I can pack into it. And, the biggest features is that it complies with the ridiculous carry on luggage size requirements of both Ryanair and Easyjet for European travel. Both airlines are some of the strictest I’ve seen for size so I generally think that if I can use this Samsonite carry on for those airlines, I can use it for all of them. Since buying this suitcase over 6 years ago, I’ve dragged it to many countries and while it is looking pretty battered, it’s still going strong and remains my favourite carry-on.

Samsonite has updated the style a bit since I bought my suitcase. It was a B-Lite back then but is now known as a Airea. The equivalent in the USA is the Ascentra.

Dimensions: 55x40x20cm (22x14x9in) | Weight: 1.8kg (6.99lb)

Samsonite Aierea (Europe) | Samsonite Ascentra (USA)

Best expandable – Samsonite Solyte DLX Expandable

Sale
Samsonite Solyte DLX Softside Expandable Luggage...
2,677 Reviews
Samsonite Solyte DLX Softside Expandable Luggage…
  • 20″ SPINNER LUGGAGE maximizes your packing power…
  • PACKING Dimensions: 19.0″ x 13.5″ x 7.75″, OVERALL…
  • 10 YEAR LIMITED WARRANTY: Samsonite products are…

This is my second go-to carry on. I tend to take it on longer trips that aren’t just weekend city breaks or winter trips. In fact, if I go on a very long trip – for several weeks or even when I’m playing digital nomad for months and years at a time – this is the luggage I take. The reason I have this in addition to my other Samsonite is the expanding capacity. Just a few extra centimetres/inch allows me to squeeze in just that bit more.

I tend to pack this as carry-on one way. Then either use it as checked luggage on the way back (if I have bought liquids like olive oil or wine). Or, if I’m flying with one of the airlines that have slightly larger carry on allowances, like British Airways, and I don’t have liquid souvenirs, I can still use it as carry on. In short, this is a lightweight, carry on suitcase that gives me just that bit of extra flexibility.

Dimensions: 55x40x20/23cm (22x14x9.5/10.5in) | Weight: 1.9kg (7.1lb)

Samsonite Aeria Expandable (Europe) | Samsonite Solyte DLX Expandable (USA)

Most hardwearing soft-shell – Antler Prestwick Cabin

ANTLER | Juno Luggage | 26 Inch Medium Suitcase…
  • Weight 7.9lb Packing capacity 73L Expanded…

Juno is a great mid-sized option if you want a bit bigger than cabin sized

Before I bought my Samsonite carry on, above, I was a big fan of Antler – I still am, and as soon as my Samsonite gives way, I’m going back to this British brand that I love. The only reason I opted for the Samsonite in the first place was literally down to what was available in the store when I went shopping. While I’ve come to love my current carry on, it can’t compete with Antler. I’d dragged my trusty 12-year-old Antler carry on all over the place until one day the zip finally gave up. Funnily enough, my brother applied a little tender loving care and the zip is now fixed. The Antler is still doing its job a further 7 years later. That’s a 20+ year life-span. My point, if you’re looking to invest in one good quality piece of luggage, I don’t think you can choose better than an Antler.

It’s a little heavier and a little smaller than my Samsonite but it’s water-resistant (a great feature for a soft-shell case) and cheaper than Samsonite. I’m afraid Antler doesn’t ship outside the USA but you may be able to find one in a local retailer or elsewhere online.

Dimensions: 55x35x20cm (22xx13.8×10.5in) | Weight: 2.23kg (4.9lb)

Antler Prestwick Cabin

Best stylish hard-shell – Level8 Textured Carry On

Sale
LEVEL8 Hard Shell Carry on Luggage Airline...
2,245 Reviews
LEVEL8 Hard Shell Carry on Luggage Airline…
  • 【Lightweight yet Hard Shell】This carry on…
  • 【Built-In TSA Code Lock With Smooth Zipper】TSA…
  • 【More Effortless Traveling】This suitcase…

This next case is definitely available in both the USA and UK and is one of the best suitcases for style. Level 8 does a range of suitcases from checked luggage to business cases to hardside carry on. They also have some lovely 2 piece sets if you want a matching pair.

I really, really, really wanted the Vintage collection carry on because my luggage buying has always been very practical, and is it really too much to want cute luggage? But unfortunately practicality won out yet again as I opted for the Textured Carry On which fits with those annoying European airline requirements. While it isn’t quite small enough for Ryanair’s minuscule size restrictions, it fits very nicely for Easyjet (and you may want to risk it for Ryanair because has anyone actually ever had their cabin-sized luggage measured at the gate?).

The Level 8 is hard shell and has a TSA-compliant lock, which is perfect if you worry about your case getting bashed around or raided. It does make the case a bit heavier, so you might need to be careful with budget airlines that have strict carry-on weight requirements. However, the handle makes up for the weight as I finally have a suitcase where the handle doesn’t catch like my Samsonite does. And it wheels oh so smoothly.

Inside, the Level 8 has great compartment mesh dividers to help with packing, which means I can save a bit of space by disposing of my packing cubes. It’s a new case and I am a little nervous about the quality of the zip which seems to catch on the corners. That said, I don’t have good form with zips (see how I broke my Antler zip yet my brother managed to fix it), so don’t necessarily take my word for the zip quality.

If you’re looking for a hard carry on that you’ll be proud to wheel through the airport, go for Level8. I’d say this case is perfect if you travel a lot for business. If you don’t fly with the nasty budget airlines, opt for the Vintage version because it really is a thing of beauty.

Dimensions: 55x42x24cm (21.5×16.6×9.3in) | Weight: 4.8kg (10.6lb)

Level 8 Textured Carry On 20″

Best carry on backpack – Kathmandu Lighthaul, 38 Litre

If you travel light and want something you can sling on your back while your travel from place to place, rather than rolling carryon luggage, a carry on backpack is the perfect solution. And the Kathmandu Lighthaul 38 litre is my suggestion. Technically, it’s a travel pack – it opens like a suitcase and you can zip away the backpack straps, which makes it ideal for stowing in a cabin. It’s also a small enough size that it complies with most airline cabin-luggage dimensions. And, for those where it doesn’t quite fit the rules (Ryanaiar, looking at you), just slightly under-fill it and, thanks to the backpack material and compression straps, it will squash down to fit.

As well as the roomy interior, with no rigid luggage handles taking up space, there’s an easy-access section for your laptop and a spacious top section for other items you might want to easily grab; in my case – snacks. Bonus: you can fit the backpack strap to function as a holdall-style bag. Overall, it’s one smart looking carry on backpack.

Dimensions: 57x33x25cm (22.4x13x9.9in) | Weight: 1.42kg (3.1lb)

Kathmandu Lighthaul, 38 litre (available in the USA, UK, Australia and New Zealand)


Carry on versus checked luggage

Considering shifting from checked luggage to carry on but not quite sure? Here’s my quick run through of the pros and cons of travelling with carry on versus checked luggage. You can read how I downsized from checked luggage to carry on.

Pros of carry on luggage

  • No extra fees to pay for checking baggage when you fly.
  • No long queue to check your bag.
  • No painful wait to collect your bag when you arrive.
  • No risk of lost luggage.
  • Cabin-luggage offers the most freedom of any bag – you can fit it almost anywhere (lockers, on buses).
  • You can walk around for hours wearing a carry on backpack, making it easy to visit places en route to your destination.

Cons of carry on luggage

  • You’re stuck with the travel sized toiletries – expensive, environmentally unfriendly pack sizes, quick to run out, urgh. Of course, you can buy when you arrive, but you’ll end up abandoning most of what you buy.
  • If you pack something that’s not allowed in checked-luggage, you’ll forfeit it at security (yes, I once accidentally tried to pack a Swiss Army Knife in carry on – “I need it for the cork screw” didn’t work).
  • It’s harder to pack for winter trips – you need to switch to some technical (lightweight but packs small) items. Here are my winter packing tips).
  • You’ll might end up having to do laundry – with limited space for things like underwear and swimwear, you might end up having to wash on the go.
  • You have to wheel it through packed airports and still risk having it ‘checked at the gate’ if there is no room when you get onboard.
  • It can be more stressful – worrying about weights and sizes and liquid volumes. Checking luggage removes the stress.

Tips for buying carry on luggage

  • Do your size research before you buy – find the exact dimensions of the strictest airlines you’ll travel with, write them down and make sure your bag is within those dimensions. Online research on official websites can make comparison easier as most list which airlines their cases comply with.
  • If you travel a lot, spend as much money as you can to get the highest quality you can – I’ve seen suitcase handles snap and wheels roll down the road. Buying a replacement at your destination can lead to an expensive and poor choice of replacement.
  • If you travel rarely, a cheap carry on suitcase might do but you might also be better trying to find a good quality brand second hand online. The quality brands were built to last.
  • Look for bags with well-designed pouches and pockets so you don’t have to unzip your entire case if you want to grab something mid-flight.
  • When checking for quality, pull the handles, look at the seams, drag your potential purchase around a bit and make sure your zips are YKK or feel high quality.
  • Check the weight of the case empty – a lightweight frame is going to make all the difference when you’re packing a large amount of stuff. It can make the difference between putting your back out or not when you swing it into the overhead bin. If you’re nervous about weight, you can buy your own luggage scales – I have a set and use them when I’m packing heavy.
  • Get the smallest suitcase you can – it’s tempting to think “the bigger the better”, however, the bigger the case, the heavier it will be because most people fill what they have to the brim.

Size requirements – all airlines

Is it me or do the rules seem to change every time you book a flight? Especially for low-cost and budget airlines. If you’re trying to buy one piece of luggage that will fit all of the requirements, it’s good to know what they are. Of course, this doesn’t future-proof your purchase. However, cabin sizes have become reasonably standardised over the last few years and if you do go for a case that fits the strictest sizes, you can be pretty confident they will fit the requirements of the airlines that have more generous baggage requirements (often the flagship carriers). Here’s a great resource if you want an up to date list of carry on luggage sizes which includes sizes as well as weight restrictions for most (all?) of the airlines around the world.

Related Articles:

Level8 case was gifted in exchange for an honest review.

Author - Jo Fitzsimons

Hi, I'm Jo, the writer behind Indiana Jo. In 2010 I quit my job as a lawyer and booked an around the world ticket. As a solo female traveller, I hopped from South America to Central America, across Asia, the Middle East and Europe. It was supposed to be a one-year trip but over a decade later, it's yet to end. I've lived in a cave, climbed down a volcano barefoot, spent years as a digital nomad, worked as a freelance travel writer, and eaten deadly Fugu. Now I'm home, back in the UK, but still travelling far and wide. You can find out more About Me.

Leave a Comment