Is Mexico Safe? From Someone Who’s Been (Pt.1)

Is Mexico Safe

Ask most people “Is Mexico Safe to visit?” and you’ll probably get a very quick and conclusive response: “No.  Mexico’s not safe.”

Of course, most people proffering these opinions have never visited Mexico. Their opinions have been formed from stories on the news. Stories their second cousin’s, cousin’s friend heard from someone he once went to school with…in Hong Kong. But still, the confidence in their advice is unfettered. Don’t go to Mexico. You’ll get kidnapped, robbed, murdered or caught in the cross-fire of the drug wars. Ergo, nothing good can ever come from a trip to Mexico.

Sigh.

As someone who has spent almost a year in Mexico across three trips and having visited 11 out of Mexico’s 31 states, I thought you might want to hear the answer to the question Is Mexico Safe? from someone who has actually been.

In this two-part article, I will first look at some of the main fears people have about visiting Mexico and compare those fears to recent (2013-2014) crime statistics in the country.

In part 2 I share my personal experiences in Mexico – how safe I felt and how that compares to the Government travel advice (UK and USA) for each of the states I’ve visited.

I’m not going to serve you anything sugar-coated. If murder rates are high, I’ll tell you (hint: they are). If there were risks in certain place, I’ll tell you (hint: there were). In fact, in part 2 I explain the worst thing that happened in each place while I was there.

Mexico has some very shady parts and crime is definitely a significant issue in some states. However, it’s absolutely possible to have an amazing, low-risk trip to the country.

The trick is knowing where to go…and where not to. And I’m hoping by the end of this two-part article, you’ll have a much better answer to the question Is Mexico Safe?

Mexico: Where Size Does Matters

Is Mexico Safe
That’s the Copper Canyon railway line you can see curving through this image. Mexico IS HUGE!

Let’s start with some demographics.

Mexico is HUGE.

Ok, that’s not very statistical, so how about this: Mexico sprawls across 761,600 square miles (that’s 1.973 million square kilometres).

If that still doesn’t mean much to you, Mexico is:

  • the 14th biggest country in the world;
  • bigger than Alaska;
  • nearly three times the size of Texas; and
  • 15 times – yes 15 times – bigger than my home country of England.

(See Wikipedia and Map Fight for details).

 And it’s not just the enormity of the land mass, Mexico is packing some people:

  • Mexico has a population of 119,713,203 million;
  • that’s more than 3 times the population of the USA’s most populated state, California, and more than twice the population of England; and
  • Mexico is the 11th most populated country in the world.

(See Wikipedia here and here).

I’ll stop with the size comparisons but I’m sure I’ve made my point – Mexico is HUGE.

But why am I so obsessed with Mexico’s size?

Simple: because when it comes to crime statistics, size matters. A lot of diversity, including levels of safety for tourists can (and does) exist in such a large space, and it’s not reasonable to write off an entire country (or strike it off your travel map) just because some bad stuff happens in some areas sometimes.

Don’t believe me? Even the US government doesn’t advise against ALL travel to Mexico.

“The U.S. Department of State warns U.S. citizens about the risk of traveling to certain places in Mexico due to threats to safety and security posed by organized criminal groups in the country… For information on security conditions in specific regions of Mexico, which can vary, travelers should reference the state-by-state assessments.”

Is Mexico Safe? The answer: it’s a state-by-state matter

Is Mexico Safe

As the US Government said, in order to answer the question is Mexico safe? you need to drill drown and answer the question on a more local or state-by-state-basis.

A word on state lines

Of course trouble doesn’t simply stop and start at the state lines so if one state comes with a warning and a neighbouring state doesn’t, use your discretion and dig deeper to fully understand the safety of the specific city, town, streets and even highways you’ll visit on your trip.

Don’t know one state from another? Here’s a handy map:

is Mexico safe

Map from: MapsOpenSource.

You’ll see from the map that Mexico is made up of 31 states, and the reality is that each state represents a different level of risk for tourist with a range from “very-very-low” to “hell-no-don’t-go” – as much as I love Mexico, there are certainly a bunch of states that even this adventure traveller wouldn’t go to right now.

Still not sure where your holiday destination is located? Here’s a broad overview of some of the main tourist destinations in Mexico and the states they sit in:

  • Baja California: Tijuana
  • Baja Sur: Cabo San Lucas, San Juan de Cabo, La Paz
  • Campeche: Campeche
  • Chiapas: San Cristobal, Palenque
  • Chihuahua and Sinaloa: Copper Canyon
  • Guanajuato: Guanajuato
  • Guerrero: Acapulco
  • Jalisco: Guadalajara, Tequila
  • Mexico: Mexico City, Teotihuacan
  • Puebla: Puebla
  • Oaxaca: Oaxaca, Puerto Escondido
  • Quintana Roo: Cancun, Playa del Carmen, Isla Mujeres, Cozumel, Tulum, Isla Holbox, Akumal
  • Yucatan: Merida

Where have I been in Mexico?

In part 2 I share full details of my experience in each of the states that I’ve visited in Mexico. Out of the list above, I’ve been to all of the tourist-popular states listed apart from Campeche, Pueblo, Guanajuato and Guerrero.

Common tourist concerns when visiting Mexico?

Is Mexico Safe
“Shoplifting? Me? No. I didn’t do it.” A shifty looking Buzz in Mexico City.

Kidnap, robbery, murder and the drug-wars are the topics that come up time and again when I ask people their concerns about visiting Mexico. Even within Colombia, I’ve met a significant number of travellers who have expressed fears of travelling to Mexico.

With those worries in mind, let’s look at the real risk of each of these things happening to your average tourist in Mexico.

A word on other crimes

Robbery, kidnapping, drug wars and murder are not the only risks in Mexico. Like all countries around the world, sexual assault, pickpocketing and scams also present risks for travellers. However, these risks aren’t especially more prevalent in Mexico than elsewhere so it’s a case of packing your usual street smarts.

Crime in Mexico: An overview

Is Mexico Safe
Accidental injury looks more likely here.

A great starting point for putting Mexican crime in context is the website How safe is Mexico?

There you will see that:

  • Mexico is safer than many locations within the USA;
  • the Yucatan Peninsula is as safe as rural USA; and
  • Mexico is safer than many other popular vacation/holiday destinations in the Caribbean.

Further, OSAC (the United States Department of State Bureau of Diplomatic Security), which has produced this very up to date (2014) report on crime in Mexico, says:

Millions of Americans safely live, work, and take vacations in Mexico every year. Security conditions vary significantly throughout the country, and for that reason the Department of State has gone to great lengths to craft and update regionally specific guidance for American citizens in Mexico. Crime varies widely in Mexico depending upon location.”

And the US Bureau of Consular Affairs says:

Millions of U.S. citizens safely visit Mexico each year for study, tourism, and business, including more than 150,000 who cross the border every day.  The Mexican government dedicates substantial resources to protect visitors to major tourist destinations, and there is no evidence that organized criminal groups have targeted U.S. visitors or residents based on their nationality.”

And, “Resort areas and tourist destinations in Mexico generally do not see the levels of drug-related violence and crime that are reported in the border region or in areas along major trafficking routes.”

However, as reassuring as all of that might be, it’s impossible to avoid the fact that crime levels are high and, as the UK Foreign Office succinctly puts it:

Most victims are Mexicans, many of them believed to be involved in criminal activity, but the security situation also poses risks for foreigners.

So, let’s look a bit closer at those main worries that foreigners have…

Am I going to get murdered in Mexico?

Is Mexico Safe
Stay on the safe routes in Mexico and you can have a trouble-free visit.

Murder seems to be a real concern for tourists in Mexico and it’s no surprise given the flood of media coverage every time a body turns up.

But what’s the likelihood that you, as a tourist, are going to get murdered in Mexico?

To try and figure this out, I looked at two pieces of information – Mexico’s latest homicide/murder rates and the list that features the “Murder Capitals” of the world i.e. the cities with the highest number of homicides (per 100,000 people).

Leading with the not so great news, Mexico features 9 times on the list: Top 50 cities by murder rate.

Equally depressing, there were 16,736 “intentional” murders in Mexico in 2013 (not including negligent homicide/manslaughter). (Based on data from January to November 2013).

But WAIT – before you strike a line through Mexico, let’s look at that data in a bit more detail.

Mexico’s Murder Capitals

The 9 Mexican cities in order of highest murder rate, are:

  • Acapulco
  • Culiacán
  • Torreón
  • Chihuahua
  • Ciudad Victoria
  • Nuevo Laredo
  • Ciudad Juárez
  • Tijuana

Now, let’s compare that to the states I listed above – the states where most tourists are likely to go:

  • Baja California: Tijuana
  • Baja Sur: Cabo San Lucas, San Juan de Cabo, La Paz
  • Campeche: Campeche
  • Chiapas: San Cristobal, Palenque
  • Chihuahua and Sinaloa: Copper Canyon
  • Guanajuato: Guanajuato
  • Guerrero: Acapulco
  • Jalisco: Guadalajara and the town of Tequila
  • Mexico: Mexico City and Teotihucan
  • Puebla: Puebla
  • Oaxaca: Oaxaca, Puerto Escondido
  • Quintana Roo: Cancun, Playa del Carmen, Isla Mujeres, Cozumel, Tulum, Isla Holbox, Akumal
  • Yucatan: Merida
Is Mexico Safe
Baja Sur – the safest place in Mexico according to the stats.

With the exceptions of Acapulco (for its beaches), Chihuahua (for starting the Copper Canyon route) and Tijuana (for cheap thrills from the USA), the list of dangerous cities and the list of tourist spots are pretty different i.e. the places where the highest numbers of murders are taking place are not the places where most tourists go on holiday/vacation.

As I explain in Part 2, I’ve visited two of the “dangerous” cities (Chihuahua and Tijuana) and by following local advice and sticking to the tourist spots, I had trouble-free visits.

However, if you crawl with fear at the idea of visiting any place on a Top 50 cities by murder rate, the answer is very simple – don’t go to those places. Mexico is big enough and beautiful enough that you can easily find another corner of the country that resents a much lower risk for tourists.

What are those lower risk places?

Baja California Sur (home of Los Cabos), Campeche and the Yucatan are Mexico’s three states with the lowest homicide rate in the country. Meanwhile, Quintana Roo (for Cancun and Playa del Carmen) comes in as eight safest.

Mexico’s Homicide Rate

As for the homicide rate, 16,736 intentional murders is way higher than most people would like to read about. Hell, it’s way higher than I’d like to read about.

However, it’s not all bad new once you start to add a bit of context to the number.

First, the homicide rate has decreased by 16% compared to the same period the year before.

Second, the homicide statistics don’t differentiate between drug-cartel related homicides and indiscriminate killings – it’s estimated that nearly 11,000 murders were attributed to drugs violence in 2013, which would makes up nearly 70% of the intentional murders in Mexico.

Finally:

“The number of U.S. citizens reported to the Department of State as murdered in Mexico was 71 in 2012 and 81 in 2013.” (US Bureau of Consular Affairs). 

Although that number has increased from 2012 to 2013, it represents a minuscule percentage of the Mexican homicide rate, and will undoubtedly include American citizens who were involved in criminal activities.

What can I do to avoid getting murdered in Mexico?

Although initial data is scary, when you dig deeper, it becomes clearer that tourists are not direct targets in Mexico and the majority of murders are drug related. With that in mind, how do you reduce your risk of danger as a tourist in Mexico?

  • try to restrict your visit to the safer states;
  • if you visit a less safe state (and even in safer states), stick to the tourist areas;
  • stay alert during you entire time in Mexico – ask for local safety advice and keep up to date on the news;
  • make sure you have extensive travel insurance – the kind that will get you out of danger if you need it; and
  • don’t go wandering into trouble – if you’re trying to buy drugs or wandering off into local territory with new-found Mexican friends, you’re putting yourself into the danger zone.

Am I going to get kidnapped and robbed in Mexico?

Is Mexico Safe
If you have wealth, try not to flaunt it.

I’ve heard a few anecdotal stories of people being kidnapped in Mexico and it’s true that kidnapping and, more specifically, express-kidnapping is a real issue in the country.

What is express kidnapping? It’s where your friendly criminals “borrow” you for 24 to 48 hours while they systematically visit ATMs with your bankcard to empty as much money as they can out of your account.

Crime stats don’t paint a pleasant picture when it comes to kidnapping in Mexico:

But, it’s only when we start to fill in the details a bit more that the picture brightens for tourists.

First, let’s look at the states with the highest kidnap rates. They are:

  • Guerrero
  • Michoacán
  • Mexico City
  • Tamaulipas
  • Morelos

With the exception of Mexico City and Guerrero for Acapulco (more on these places in a minute), these are once again states that most tourists are unlikely to visit.

Not only that, let’s put that large kidnapping rate into some sort of context.

Remember at the beginning of this article where I droned on tirelessly about the size of Mexico, and where I mentioned that there are over 119 million people living in Mexico…well, comparing that population with the estimated kidnap rate (105,682), the risk of kidnap in Mexico is actually less than 0.1%.

Further, when you look at the risk to non-locals, the number of kidnappings gets dramatically smaller:

Nearly 70 kidnappings of U.S. citizens were reported to the U.S. Embassy and consulates in Mexico between January and June of 2014.” (the US Bureau of Consular Affairs)

Although the US Bureau of Consular Affairs doesn’t break those numbers down by expats, business or tourists, this piece of guidance from the Bureau sheds some further light:

“Of particular safety concern are casinos, sportsbooks, or other gambling establishments and adult entertainment establishments.  U.S. government personnel are specifically prohibited from patronizing these establishments in the states of Coahuila, Durango, Zacatecas, Aguascalientes, San Luis Potosi, Nuevo Leon, and Tamaulipas.”

In short, the kidnap risk seems to be concentrated in locations and involve activities that your average tourist won’t come into contact with.

Perhaps the best news of all if you want to reduce your kidnap risk – looking poor is your best defence. As OSAC says:

“Armed robberies, “express” kidnappings, car thefts, carjackings, credit card fraud, and various forms of residential and street crime are daily concerns. The low rate of convictions of criminals contributes to the high crime rate. Criminals select victims based on an appearance of prosperity, vulnerability, or a lack of awareness. Displays of wealth are magnets for thieves in Mexico City. Wearing expensive jewelry, watches, and displays of large amounts of cash draw unwanted attention. Jewelry and expensive watches and cellular phones can be sold easily in vast illegal markets. Although Mexico employs strict gun-control laws, criminals are usually armed with handguns (or knives) when carrying out street crime.”

A word on street taxis in Mexico

Is Mexico Safe
The beautiful Bellas Artes museum in Mexico.

I said I’d come back to the subject of kidnappings in Mexico City. So, here we are…

I’ve travelled through Mexico city a handful of times and each time (after my first time, when I was pretty cautious), I felt very safe…until it came to the street taxi.

One of the safest ways to travel in most cities around the world is by hailing a cab. But sadly that’s not the case in Mexico City. Commonly involved in gang crime and a significant means of procuring victims for express-kidnappings, the best advice I could offer for anyone visiting Mexico is to steer clear of the street taxis in Mexico City.

As OSAC says:

One simple way to lessen one’s chances of becoming a victim of street crime in Mexico City is to avoid the use of “Libre” taxi cabs. Due to the danger involved in utilizing “Libre” taxis, and the increased difficulty in determining the difference between the different types of taxis, the best practice is to avoid hailing taxis in the street entirely. Instead, call, or have the merchant you are visiting call a radio dispatched “Sitio” taxi.”

A word on Acapulco

You might have noticed that Guerrero, home state of Acapulco, keeps featuring on the “dicey locations” lists.

As keen as I am to visit Acapulco’s beaches, for now I’ve taken the view that the crime risk is too high – especially when there are plenty of other beaches to enjoy in Mexico. Of course, you should take your own view on whether to visit Acapulco or not, but do take into consideration that Guerrero doesn’t do too well when it comes to crime stats in Mexico.

A word on car jacking and highway robberies in Mexico

Highway robbery may sound like something out of a western movie but for motorists in Mexico it’s a real risks.

As the US Bureau of Consular Affairs says:

“Carjacking and highway robbery are serious problems in many parts of the border region… There are indications that criminals target newer and larger vehicles, especially dark-colored SUVs.  However, even drivers of old sedans and buses coming from the United States have been targeted.”

The advice:

“To reduce risk when traveling by road, we strongly urge you to travel between cities throughout Mexico only during daylight hours, to avoid isolated roads, and to use toll roads.”

What can you do to avoid getting robbed or being a kidnap victim in Mexico?

Kidnapping, although a concern for many, doesn’t appear to present a significant risk (statistically) for tourists travelling to the main travel destinations. Still, to keep the risk low:

  • lend your Rolex to your friend at home while you travel to Mexico. I suspect one of the major reasons I’ve not run into trouble in Mexico is because I (intentionally) don’t look like I’m worth robbing!
  • don’t take the street taxis in Mexico City. I’ve already written about the problem of street taxis in my article My 20 Worst Travel Stories together with advice for dealing with taxis in Mexico;
  • avoid the states/activities that represent the highest kidnap risks;
  • a particularly good tip from the UK Foreign office: “Be discreet about discussing your financial or business affairs in places where you may be overheard by others.”;
  • consider discussing your travel plans with your bank and insurance company if you’re concerned or likely to engage in risky (kidnap-appealing) business in Mexico; and
  • if the worst happens – express kidnapping or car jacking – co-operate. There’s no need to contribute to Mexico’s murder stats!

Am I going to get caught in the cross-fire of the drug cartels?

Is Mexico Safe

Mexico is in an unfortunate position. As the last drug handover point between Latin America and the USA (around 90% of the USA’s cocaine comes via Mexico), and with an industry that is estimated to be worth almost $50 billion, it’s no great surprise that the USA-Mexico border areas are volatile and risky areas to visit.

There are a bunch of active drug cartels in Mexico (you can read about them here) and in 2013 it was estimated that nearly 11,000 people were killed due to Mexican drug warfare.

However, the good news is that you, as a tourist, are not the target.

“To date, criminal groups have not shown a pattern of targeting innocent civilians for political purposes or espousing political motivation for their actions.” (OSAC)

And, the drug wars are largely restricted to a small handful of states. Here’s a handy map highlighting where the main mafia cartels are at work (shown in red):

is mexico safe

 Source: Wikipedia.

The location-specific nature of Mexico’s drug war is highlighted by the UK Foreign Office:

“Drug-related violence in Mexico has increased over recent years. The violence is concentrated in specific areas, and some regions are almost completely spared. Make sure you research your destination thoroughly.” and

“Drug-related violence is a particular problem in the northern states of Sonora, Chihuahua, Coahuila, Nuevo Leon, Tamaulipas, Sinaloa and Durango, and also in Guerrero, Jalisco, Michoacán and Nayarit. Armed clashes between security forces and drug groups can occur at any time without warning. You should exercise extreme caution outside of tourist areas in all of these states.”

Although this list of states is longer than the states highlighted on the map, the locations are still, largely, places where tourists don’t tend to go (with the exception of Chihuahua and Sinaloa (for the start and end of Copper Canyon), Tijuana and Guadalajara.

What can you do to avoid getting caught up in the cartel cross-fire in Mexico?

For the reasons above, I’m pretty confident saying that, unless you’re mucking around in cartel territory, the chance of you as a tourist getting caught up in the cross-fire of the drug wars is pretty low. Still, to keep your risk low:

  • don’t visit the states of the cartel strongholds;
  • if you do visit, like I did when I went to Chihuahua, Sinaloa and Tijuana, stick to the tourist spots, minimise the length of time you spend there and adhere to the local safety advice;
  • don’t go looking for trouble i.e. don’t go making deals with the local drug kingpin just for the sake of some cheap(er than you’d get outside of Mexico) thrills.

Tourism in Mexico

Is Mexico Safe
The colours of the water – just one reason tourists will always feel drawn to Mexico.

Fear is uniquely individual and I accept that the above stats may put a good number of you off visiting Mexico (even within the context of Mexico’s size and given that much of the trouble is concentrated in states you’re unlikely to visit).

If that’s the case, fair enough. The point of leisure travel is to enjoy yourself and if you’re not going to be able to relax through fear of something bad happening, then you’re better off going somewhere else (Spain, Italy and Hawaii are good, safe alternative). At least you’ve done some research before making an informed decision.

However, the reality is that tourism numbers are high in Mexico (11.8 million visitors arrived by air in 2013), those numbers are growing (up 9% compared to 2012) and, most importantly, the majority of tourist – myself included – visit Mexico without experiencing any trouble.

In part 2 I share with you my experience – is Mexico safe (or does it at least feel safe) in reality?

A small disclaimer: Crime in Mexico is a complicated subject with a lot of data from myriad sources. I’m no expert on the topic. I’ve pulled together this article based on the best information and most reliable sources I’ve been able to find. My aim is to inform people about Mexico. If you have conflicting or more relevant information that I have missed, please send it to me and I’ll happily update this article. 

Have you been to Mexico? Did you have a safe trip? Do you have any additional concerns about travelling to Mexico? Let me know in the comments below. 

If you liked this article, you might be interested to read my related articles:

Is Mexico Safe? From Someone Who’s Been (Part 2)

Best Things to Do in Yucatan Peninsula, Mexico

Guide to Swimming with Whale Sharks in Mexico

How to Drink Tequila Like A Mexican

Luxury in Los Cabos without Visiting a Resort

Quick and Easy Guacamole Recipe from Mexico

Travel Insurance: Don’t Get Screwed by the Small Print

Article written by

Jo Fitzsimons is a freelance travel writer who has visited over 50 countries. www.indianajo.com is the place where she shares destination details, travel itineraries, planning and booking tips and trip tales. Her aim: to help you plan your travel adventure on your terms and to your budget.

12 Responses

  1. Planning An Affordable Copper Canyon Tour Itinerary | Indiana Jo

    […] Is Mexico Safe? The Answer from Someone Who’s Been (Part 1)  – Looking at the facts and… […]

  2. Kevin Bates
    Kevin Bates at | | Reply

    things do change..I was in Torreon , Mexico in July 2015..seemed peaceful and calm

    but I did read that 2 to 3 years prior it had been a hotbed of drug violence between warring gangs..the police force apparently quite corrupt..the mayor ending up firing the entire police force except for one person, and bring the military into town for a period to enforce law & order until a new police force could be formed..
    the violence level was WAY down & it was a fairly calm place in 2015

    Maybe similar to changes in Medellin Colombia in the Pablo Escobar era vs. later ?

  3. An Itinerary Through Real Jamaica
    An Itinerary Through Real Jamaica at |

    […] also written about the safety of several destinations that many people are nervous about visiting (Mexico, Naples, Colombia and Detroit to name a […]

  4. Is Mexico Safe? From someone who’s been (pt.2)

    […] Part 1 I look at some of the main fears people have about visiting Mexico and compare those fears to […]

  5. Is Detroit Safe? The Answer From Someone Who's Been | Indiana Jo

    […] statistics about Detroit on a neighbourhood by neighbourhood basis, which is a shame because, just like Mexico, Detroit’s high crime levels are not representative of all parts of Detroit – some […]

  6. Mary Ellen
    Mary Ellen at | | Reply

    Due to increased drug cartel activity, Baja California Sur is NOT the safest place to visit anymore esp. in the La Paz area. So one needs to read current info before leaving as it changes sometimes month to month in Mexico.

  7. Daniel Crowe
    Daniel Crowe at | | Reply

    Mexico is a great tourist destination for people who love adventures and traveling. When it comes to safety, you need to practice safety measures like being extra careful while traveling on their thoroughfares.

  8. The Best Places to Visit in Colombia | Indiana Jo

    […] all honestly, it wasn’t until I was researching the crime statistics for an article about Safety in Mexico that I realised that Cali is currently number 4 on the list of the 50 most dangerous cities in the […]

Please comment with your real name using good manners.

Leave a Reply